
My last post was about
chess cheaters and the best way to remove them from our beloved game. This post started a thread on rec.games.chess.misc and generated a very insightful comment that pointed out a shortcoming in the post. I was negligent in discussing what are valid prizes. This is a big deal because I believe that you shouldn't point out problems unless you are willing to provide a solution or at least work toward finding one. As you can probably guess this post will be all about prizes that are enticing to players, but are not the prizes cheaters will go after.
Let me start with cash. There is nothing wrong with cash prizes. The problem is excessive cash prizes. A cash prize that covers the tournament expenses is fine. A cash prize that's equivalent to a new car is not. Unfortunately it's too hard to distinguish between what's a safe amount and what's too much so it's probably a good idea to just stay away from cash. I am convinced that the players that are motivated by cash are in a small minority of players so eliminating this from all sections except the open shouldn't hurt attendance.
Now on to what I consider prizes that everyone can feel good about providing. Let's start with the old standby,
trophies. Trophies are wonderful. Unlike money a trophy last forever. It's a great reminder of an event that you did well at and they say something about you. I did a little research and found that trophies have come a long way from when I was a little kid. We are not limited to plastic and marble bases anymore. The choices for trophies has grown considerably and the material ranges from plastic to crystal and everything in between. The price range for these items also varies considerably depending on the quality of the material and the complexity of the design. With all these options you can see that we could play and win several tournaments without getting the same kind of trophy twice.
The final prizes I would like to mention are books/equipment. These types of prizes are great because I can't think of a single chess player that isn't always trying to get there hands on more chess stuff. Books, DVD's, clocks, and high end chess sets are prizes that can be useful to chess players. Along these lines a training session with a local GM would also be very appealing. These prizes are only appealing to chess players. What would a chess cheat do with a free lesson?
The idea of moving away from cash prizes is not a new and radical change. There are plenty of other very successful competitive events that never give out money. I can't think of a 5K run that gives much more then t-shirts and many racquetball and orienteering races give shoes and other equipment as prizes. Chess at the non-professional level should be all about the love of the game not the cash prize.
Labels: Chess Cheats