Monday, September 25, 2006
In 2005, an estimated 70 million American households spent $7 billion to buy vitamin supplements. So what does this have to do with chess? Well the truth of the matter is that the chess community is not immune to the advertised potential of some of these supplements.
The promise of better memory or the ability to focus for longer periods of time is too tempting for any serious chess player to ignore. But do any of them work? To explore this question I did what most of you would do and went straight to the web. If you are inclined I recommend doing a Google search on memory vitamins from the search bar on this page. The number of hits for my search was over six million! With so many choices I decided to focus on the three I saw mentioned the most: DMAE , Ginkgo Biloba, and Gotu Kola. Besides seeing these mentioned most frequently these were also the ones I was able to get the most unbiased reports on.
DMAE
Dimethylaminoethanol, also known as DMAE or dimethylethanolamine, is an organic compound. This compound also goes by the names of N,N-dimethyl-2-aminoethanol, beta-dimethylaminoethyl alcohol, beta-hydroxyethyldimethylamine and Deanol. It is a liquid with a color that ranges from clear to pale yellow.
DMAE is a naturally occurring nutrient found in high concentrations in fish.
Promises:
DMAE can elevate one's mood, counter depression, and boost cognitive functions (such as memory and concentration), and even increase intelligence. These benefits stem from this nutrient's role in manufacturing acetylcholine, a crucial neurotransmitter that is responsible for healthy mental functioning.
Data Source Nutritional Supplement Info
Side Effects:
I found a source which warned against using DMAE if you suffer from epilepsy, bipolar disorder, or manic depression.
Data Source Lowering Cholesterol
Clinical Results:
While there are some test that show kids with ADD appear to be helped by taking it the majority of the scientifically run test could not find any significant increase in memory or brain performance.
Data Source NYU School of Medicine
Gotu Kola
Centella asiatica is a small herbaceous annual plant of the family Apiaceae, native to Asia. Common names include Gotu Kola, Asiatic Pennywort, Antanan, Pegaga, and Brahmi (although this last name is shared with Bacopa monnieri and other herbs). It is used as a medicinal herb in Ayurvedic medicine and traditional Chinese medicine.
Gotu kola is a slender, creeping plant that grows commonly in swampy areas of
Data Source Herbal Information Center
Promises:
I was going to list all advertise beneficial properties of the herb, but after reading several pages I discovered that this plant can do it all. Its good for whatever ails you. It can increase mental ability and even cure leprosy.
Data Source Herbal Information Center
Side Effects:
Side effects are rare but may include skin allergy and burning sensations (with external use), headache, stomach upset, nausea, dizziness, and extreme drowsiness. These side effects tend to occur with high doses of gotu kola.
The use of gotu kola for more than 6 weeks is not recommended. People taking the herb for an extended period of time (up to 6 weeks) should take a 2-week break before taking the herb again.
Asiaticoside, a major component of gotu kola, has also been associated with tumor growth in mice. Though more studies are needed, it is wise for anyone with a history of precancerous or cancerous skin lesions, such as squamous cell, basal cell skin cancer, or melanoma to refrain from taking this herb.
Data Source Maryland Medical Center
Clinical Results:
I am going to have to say that the jury is still out on whether this herb can do all that they claim. I found several sites that gave this herb amazing credit for treating several ailments, but whenever mental functions was mentioned there was no clinical test which confirmed it would help you perform.
Data Source Maryland Medical Center
Ginkgo Biloba
The Ginkgo (Ginkgo biloba), frequently misspelled as "Gingko", and sometimes known as the Maidenhair Tree, is a unique tree with no close living relatives. It is classified in its own division, the Ginkgophyta, comprising the single class Ginkgoopsida, order Ginkgoales, family Ginkgoaceae, genus Ginkgo and just the one species. It is one of the best known examples of a living fossil. In the past it has also been placed in the divisions Spermatophyta or Pinophyta. Ginkgo is a gymnosperm (as opposed to an angiosperm), meaning "naked seed"; its seeds are not protected by an ovary wall and hence, the berry-like structures produced by female ginkgo trees are technically not fruit.
For centuries it was thought to be extinct in the wild, but is now known to grow wild in at least two small areas in Zhejiang province in eastern China, in the Tian Mu Shan Reserve. However, as this area has known human activity for over a thousand years, the wild status of ginkgos there is as yet uncertain.
Promises:
Ginkgo is a medicinal herb that is said to be effective in helping treat the following conditions: Arterial circulatory problems, Cerebral atherosclerosis, Cerebral edema, Cerebral vascular insufficiency, Cochlear deafness, Diminished sight and hearing ability due to vascular insufficiency, Impairment of memory and/or ability to concentrate, Intermittent claudication as a result of arterial obstruction, Retinopathy, Senility, Sensitivity to cold in the extremities due to peripheral circulatory insufficiency, Short-term memory loss, Tinnitus (of a vascular origin) Vascular Diseases, and Vertigo (of a vascular origin). It has been considered especially helpful in cases Alzheimer's disease and dementia. It is usually advisable to purchase a standardized version of this herb. The average Ginkgo Biloba preparation is a 50:1 extract standardized to 24% of the ginkgo flavonone glycosides. It can be taken as a capsule, pill, or tincture.
Overall, ginkgo leaf extract (used in most commercial products) appears to be well tolerated in most healthy adults at recommended doses for up to six months. In several reviews, ginkgo was associated with similar rates of side effects as placebo (sugar pill). Minor symptoms including headache, nausea, and intestinal complaints have been reported.
Clinical Results:
Multiple clinical trials have evaluated ginkgo for a syndrome called "cerebral insufficiency." This condition, more commonly diagnosed in Europe than the


